"Politicians care about the next election.
Leaders care about the next generation."
I saw this on a bumper sticker in front of me as I drove to work and felt cranky about the NY State defeat of marriage equality. Where are the other Diane Savino-like people who understand the difference between sacramental and civil marriage and the right to equality?
Clearly we have tons of politicians and few leaders. Will no one take the risk to stand up and speak to prejudice and inequality? I think I see the return of the label from my old blog, borrowed from the brilliant Suzy... Jesus, I'm sick of these people.
Before I get going, let me address anyone who might not be so anti-gay marriage but who just can't quite get their arms around it either. To them I say, you may think that you don't know any gay folks... I am sure you do. You may think it is weird because you focus on the sex and not the love. You may think it is dangerous. You need to go meet some gay people with families and you will find a very different story. That and you need to consider watching this movie.
Of course we also had to swallow the bitter pill of loss as we held onto our aching heads and clutched our breaking hearts as we listened to a soundtrack of "take your name off your phone." Poof. Be gone do-gooder-cheaters, be gone! I could care less about your sexual morality, so please do me the favor of not getting up in mine or the morality of others.
What is it with this myth of the "sanctity of marriage?" I am so over it! Sanctity of marriage, sacramental or civil, comes from the eye and the heart of the beholders, not from law.
There is no hard and fast rule to why people remain loyal in their relationships. As it stands today, there is very little in our culture or society that encourages loyalty, fidelity and community. From job security to health care, from tax reform to tea baggers we see this. Consider also the endless barrage of advertising that points us to the "next great thing" that we *must* possess, there is an underlying but clear message that what we have has no worth and this "next" thing will be the one to bring us happiness. There is no happiness, there is just the next. There is no fidelity either and I do not say that with in some high minded overarching voice, it is just sadly true.
Now the shadow side of loyalty is a false loyalty that encourages people to stay in all kinds of bad relationships and that is not good either. In fact that is very dangerous, especially when the relationship is abusive. Loyalty - blind loyalty is not any better than the lack of it really.
So now back to the whole issue of marriage equality... Everyone on the right, from politicians who only care about the next vote and the so-called upstanding members of society who think that same-sex marriage will encourage bestiality are beating the drum of "one-man-one-woman" over and over again. And yes, I know who else is screaming about this and rejoicing over the NY state and all other marriage equality losses.
As if this were not enough, somebody I know and love introduced me to this company. I clearly missed some advertising and PR boat, as I had never heard of them before.
Ah yes - the sanctity of marriage alright. This couple is married... just not to each other.
This couple is not married, but they would like to be if you would stay out of their business.


If the gay haters want to get even with us and make sure we stop having gay sex, they should legalize same sex marriage.
ReplyDeleteNothing kills a sex drive faster than marriage, in my opinion.
:D
I don't understand why anyone like you would want to continue to work for the Catholic church. How can you describe yourself as a "passionate" Catholic and cope with all the feelings you've been writing about lately? My head would explode! It's like that Bible verse about serving two masters... it's just not possible. My 2 cents.
ReplyDeleteHelene
Brava, Fran. I'm so glad you are on our side.
ReplyDeleteFolks can follow this issue from my perspective at Gay Married Californian
@Karen Zipdrive - I am always glad to see you here. Rather than say anything unseemly, I will simply say that what you think about marriage is not always true. (*blushes*)
ReplyDelete@Helene - Hi Helene, good to have you stop by and comment, thank you. My head is not exploding, I do not serve two masters, just one.
My blogging friend Claire has written about Miriam Therese Winters' book "Defecting in Place. I think I am somewhat doing that.
I am very loyal to my church and my loyalty does not preclude questioning and challenging. I also do not think that the Catholic church should be in the business of civil marriage, I do think that the Catholic church should be focused on the business of sacramental marriage.
If you read my words as complaints, that is the fault of my words I guess. If it were that bad I would leave... and I am not even close to leaving!
My feelings that you perceive are the frustration with a hypocritical society and further frustration with *any* churches that are so vociferous on this matter.
Let me rephrase that - vociferous in the public square in this way at this time is better put.
Does that make sense? Please comment further or email me if you would like.
@IT - Thanks. I am glad that you put your link in, I should have done so in the post itself.
That said, I do not see it as a matter of sides but rather as a matter of equality for all. If someone does not want to accept your marriage they do not have to. It pains me that your marriage is threatened by others who have a say in it.
However - I guess you are right,I sometimes have favorites and you are one of them. Your sense of fidelity trumps many others that I see out there and it humbles me. And I am speaking of fidelity to your BP and to your world; it brings me to my knees.
I just got home. Once again I had the privilege to serve God and God's people at yet another beautiful liturgy.
ReplyDeleteAs it happened, with this post on my mind and with some comments that I left over at The Friends of Jake that is not likely to earn me any friends, I heard a homily that as essentially about unity.
Unity.
Love.
Forgiveness.
That is what church is about for me. Not having it my way versus your way, but our way in some crazy way together.
I know that is terribly idealistic but it what I want and what I try to be.
Generally I suck at it, but I keep trying.
This comment has been removed by the author.
ReplyDelete(That was me, wrong Blogger account)
ReplyDeleteThanks for your kind words, Fran, here and at Friends.
Thanks for all of your thinking and writing on this topic, Fran.
ReplyDeleteI'd quibble with one thing. I didn't think "For the Bible Tells Me So" was so good a contribution to this debate. Had some flaws.
FYI:
http://paulsnatchko.blogspot.com/2007/10/disappointed.html
Lurker, here. Just wanted to pop in and say I agree with you on the past couple posts. And your first tag says it all for me.
ReplyDelete@IT - Got it, I thought that might be you! Thank you again and I am always glad that we are in community.
ReplyDelete@Paul Snatchko - Hi Paul, thank you for your comment. I found Diane Savino's video via your blog and have been on this rant since.
I appreciate what you said about FTBTMS at your blog. You did make some good points there. Thanks for that link - it was before I knew you, so I had not seen it!
@Garpu - welcome to the comment box here and for your reading, I thank you. I was hesitant to use that tag because I really don't want to be so angry and prejudicial, but sometimes it just works.
I hope you'll accept my apology for not migrating over here sooner from your old blog. Somehow I must have missed this. Reading here makes me realize how much I have missed your writing and perspective. :)
ReplyDelete